Will Intel's new Viiv technology really be able to take the home entertainment market by storm? I don't think that media PCs fare well in the market because they are just that: PCs. If you look at your DVD player it has one function, to play DVDs. Your stereo has one purpose, to play CDs and tune into radio stations. Your TiVo has the purpose of scheduling TV programs. Granted, a TiVo is just a small computer, but it's operating system is dedicated to just recording programs (yes you can hack it, but I'm trying to be simplistic).
My point? Viiv (pronounced Vive, like Five but with the "F" replaced with a "V") hopes to be an all-in-one home entertainment system. This is a wonderous prospect to have all of your electronics in one tiny little box, but it's a pretty tall order to fill. Viiv will be using Microsoft's Windows XP Media Center Edition 2005. What's the problem with this? It's not a stand alone media center operating system. It's just Windows XP with a multimedia application on top of it.
What's the problem with this? Have you seen how bloated Windows can be? You can't leave it on for a long time and expect it to work everytime without a few hiccups, burps, and farts along the way. Another issue is the boot time. It takes about 30 seconds upto about 90 seconds before you can actually log into Windows. Depending on how much stuff needs to load into the service tray, it could be about another 2 or 3 minutes before you are ready to go. So, that's about 4:30? When you turn on your DVD player it takes a couple of seconds to start, few seconds to load the DVD, and you're ready to go. I've never had a TiVo, but I'm sure it doesn't take 4.5 minutes to start up.
Could there be a solution? Of course there is! Microsoft just needs to build, from scratch, a media center operating system that does not need the different services that are built into Windows. A media center operating system should only deal with music, video, and pictures. That's it. Since it will probably be connected to the Internet, Microsoft should make security a top priority. Even though you shouldn't have any personal information on there, it will be connected to a network it can act as a gateway to other computers.
At any rate, I think Intel is being bold in trying to make a media center platform. When it's all been said and done, I think that the Intel Viiv will not be a big success and will just become another multimedia PC flop.